It's a points thing. Go under "high scores", then click on the words "monthly competitions". If you aren't at least #50 on the high-scoring list, you don't qualify for either % or speed competitions. It's to keep players who only do a handful of puzzles per month from coming away with a trophy. With 401 puzzles, you were probably in the mid-70s.
La, la, la - la - la - la....